Black Sun

    Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs

    by Johann Hari

    Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs

    by Johann Hari

    The book examines how the war on drugs began, how addiction has been widely misunderstood, and what has happened in countries that have moved away from prohibition. Its central argument is that many common beliefs about drug use are contradicted by the available evidence.

    According to the book, the origins of the war on drugs can be traced through three figures: Harry Anslinger, Billie Holiday, and Arnold Rothstein.

    1. Harry Anslinger

    Harry Anslinger was the first commissioner of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics and pursued a sustained campaign against drugs, organized crime, and jazz culture. Hari documents that Anslinger's views and public statements were openly racist. At a time when many officials dismissed the Mafia as a myth, Anslinger insisted on its existence and was eventually proven correct. Hari suggests that this vindication reinforced Anslinger's conviction that he understood threats others could not see, and it hardened his belief that all drugs were uniformly destructive, despite evidence to the contrary. Institutional pressures also played a role: his bureau's survival depended on the perceived seriousness of the threat it was created to fight. The broader cultural climate contributed as well. The Harrison Narcotics Act of 1914, passed shortly before the United States entered the First World War, restricted cocaine and opiates, which had previously been used across racial and social classes and were common ingredients in over-the-counter medicines. Anslinger, who took office in 1930, expanded this framework and soon directed his campaign toward marijuana.

    2. Billie Holiday

    Billie Holiday was a celebrated jazz singer whose childhood was marked by severe trauma, including sexual abuse and forced prostitution, in addition to the pervasive racism of the era. She later turned to heroin, which Hari presents as a means of easing profound emotional suffering. This pattern is consistent with a broader observation in addiction research: many people who develop severe addictions have histories of significant adversity, often beginning in childhood. Anslinger initially sought to target jazz musicians through marijuana, despite the fact that, by Hari's account, 29 of the 30 medical experts he consulted rejected the claim that marijuana was dangerous. "He reassured politicians that his crackdown would affect not 'the good musicians, but the jazz type.'" When that campaign stalled, he focused on Holiday and her heroin use. Holiday was a major artist at the height of her influence, and Hari argues that persistent harassment and prosecution contributed to her early death. Her case became an emblematic casualty of a policy that would eventually extend worldwide.

    According to the author, "the main reason given for banning drugs - the reason obsessing the men who launched this war - was that blacks, Mexicans, and Chinese were using these chemicals, forgetting their place, and menacing white people." Anslinger portrayed Black Americans as the primary users of dangerous substances and as the central threat to public order. Hari also describes how Anslinger's agents used drugs alongside the people they were investigating and, in some cases, spiked the drinks of unsuspecting individuals. The agents' own drug use was justified as a necessary part of enforcement, while white users were rarely targeted. Hari concludes that racial prejudice was a central driver of early drug policy.

    Racism, however, was not the only factor. As in many historical episodes, the pursuit of power and profit also shaped the war on drugs.

    Hari reports that some of Anslinger's officers were themselves paid off by organized crime. There is no evidence that Anslinger was personally involved in these arrangements, and his motives appear to have been rooted in ideological conviction, but corruption within his bureau was documented. Organized crime had a clear financial interest in prohibition: once drugs were illegal, criminal suppliers could charge vastly more than the cost of production. Hari notes that morphine produced for about two cents could be sold for a dollar, a fiftyfold markup. A comparable pattern appears in modern pharmaceutical pricing, as described in an article from The National Library of Medicine on companies charging many times the production cost for life-saving medicine.

    The physician Henry Smith Williams, who had once regarded drug users as worthless, became one of the first to recognize these dynamics. He began investigating Anslinger's bureau after his brother, also a doctor, was arrested for prescribing opiates to patients, a practice that had been legal. Hari reports that tens of thousands of doctors were prosecuted in this period and that the large majority were convicted. Williams was concerned not only for his brother but for the broader consequences, since small doses of morphine had been used routinely across society. Over the course of his investigation, he abandoned his earlier contempt for drug users and devoted considerable effort to helping them. His findings were troubling: prohibition had created an illegal smuggling industry and driven prices so high that many users turned to crime to sustain their supply. "'The United States government, as represented by its anti-drug officers,' Henry explained, had just become 'the greatest and most potent maker of criminals in any recent century.'" In Williams's analysis, prohibition itself generated much of the danger and criminality associated with drug use. Before the ban, users could obtain these substances without breaking the law.

    Anslinger later drew on Cold War fears of Communism, claiming that China was deliberately undermining American society by supplying drugs, even though his own agents found no evidence for the claim. Many countries initially resisted adopting American-style prohibition. According to Hari, the United States applied diplomatic and economic pressure, including threats to trade relationships, to secure their cooperation. Through this pressure, Anslinger's rigid convictions played an outsized role in shaping international drug policy.

    When confronted with evidence that contradicted his views, Anslinger tended to respond with attacks, and when his claims were disproven, he often turned to discrediting the character of the doctors who challenged him. One of those critics stated that Anslinger "[has] led this country to treat scientific questions the way such matters were handled in the Middle Ages."

    3. Arnold Rothstein

    The third figure, Arnold Rothstein, is credited with pioneering the structure of modern organized crime. After drugs were prohibited, he gained control of much of the heroin and cocaine trade on the East Coast. He ran his operation as a business focused on profit, enforced through violence. His murder in 1928 fragmented his organization and set off a series of gang conflicts, in which each successor group became more violent in order to gain dominance. Hari's broader point is structural: when a market is pushed outside the law, disputes cannot be settled through courts or contracts, so violence becomes the primary means of control, and competitors escalate violence to survive.

    The book identifies several widely held misconceptions about drug use and examines the evidence against them:

    1. 1.
      Most drug-related killings are caused by people under the influence of drugs. "Professor Paul Goldstein of the University of Illinois conducted a detailed study in which he and his team looked at every killing identified as drug-related in New York City in 1986." The study found that only about 7.5% of these killings were committed by someone under the influence of a drug, and about 2% by users trying to fund a habit. The remaining cases, roughly 90%, were connected to violence within the illegal drug market itself. The evidence suggests that the violence stems largely from the illegal trade rather than from the pharmacological effects of the drugs.
    2. 2.
      Most drug users are non-white. "In fact, the evidence suggests white people are slightly more likely to use and sell drugs." This finding directly contradicts the racial assumptions that shaped early enforcement.
    3. 3.
      Murder rates are consistent across time. "Professor Jeffrey Miron of Harvard University has shown that the murder rate has dramatically increased twice in U.S. history - and both times were during periods when prohibition of drugs was dramatically escalated." Miron's work links these increases to prohibition rather than to drug use itself. "Take the drug trade away from criminals, he calculates, and it would reduce the homicide rate in the United States by between 25 and 75 percent." Even the lower end of this estimate represents a substantial reduction.
    4. 4.
      Arresting drug dealers will resolve the violence. The book describes a case in which 80% of the drug dealers in a particular area were arrested within a short period. Within a week, drug activity had returned to its previous levels. As long as demand remains and economic opportunities are limited, new sellers readily replace those who are removed.
    5. 5.
      Not very many people use drugs. "More than 50% of Americans have breached the drug law." Even if this figure is imprecise, it indicates that illegal drug use is far more common than is generally assumed. Hari argues that minorities and poor communities bear the brunt of enforcement because "where a law is that widely broken, you can't possibly enforce it against every lawbreaker... so you keep targeting the weak." This unequal enforcement is one of the book's recurring themes: those with wealth and influence are far less likely to face consequences. The physician Andrew Weil observed that "'the ubiquity of drug use is so striking... it must represent a basic human appetite." Psychoactive substances appear across cultures and religious traditions throughout history. Alcohol and caffeine are also drugs, and habitual use of caffeine is widespread and socially accepted.
    6. 6.
      Prisons are full of murderers and rapists. According to the source Hari cites, "some 90 percent of the inmates... are here because of a drug-related problem[s]." The book does not specify how many of these cases involve violence, but Hari argues that a large share of the war's casualties are ordinary people who were caught engaging in behavior that a majority of Americans have also engaged in. A criminal record severely limits employment and other opportunities after release, which in turn increases the likelihood of reoffending. For those drawn into gangs or cartels, leaving is often not a realistic option: cartels may threaten not only the individual but their entire family. Hari also documents how rarely cartel violence is punished. In Ciudad Juárez, once among the most violent cities in the world, he reports a conviction rate of about 2%. Residents he interviewed described violence so frequent that people became desensitized to shootings, public executions, and the display of bodies. "In 2012... Michele Leonhart, the head of the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, said that the level of violence and death in Mexico is in fact 'a sign of success in the fight against drugs.'" Hari presents this statement as an example of how official measures of success can become detached from human outcomes.
    7. 7.
      The war on drugs is working. The evidence does not support this claim. Drug use in the United States has increased over the course of the drug war, as discussed later in this summary.
    8. 8.
      Drug users are dangerous. "All we see in the public sphere are casualties. The unharmed 90 percent use drugs in private, and we rarely hear about it or see it. The damaged 10 percent, by contrast, are the only people we ever see using drugs out on the streets." This pattern reflects a form of availability bias: the most visible cases shape public perception, even when they are unrepresentative. Negativity bias, the tendency to give greater weight to negative information than to positive information, compounds the effect. The large majority of users who live ordinary, stable lives rarely attract media attention.
    9. 9.
      Anyone can get addicted to drugs. Drug use among American soldiers during the Vietnam War is a frequently cited counterexample. Research led by Lee Robins found that a substantial proportion of soldiers used heroin during their service and about 20% showed signs of addiction, yet roughly 95% of those who were addicted did not resume addiction within a year of returning home. These were often soldiers exposed to significant trauma, and still most stopped once their environment changed. The explanation Hari offers is that people who develop lasting addictions frequently carry significant emotional pain before they ever use a drug, and drugs provide relief. As one user put it, "it meets a need. It takes away the pain, for a while." Hari argues that psychological and environmental factors are far more decisive than the chemical properties of the substance.
    10. 10.
      Drug addiction is primarily biological. The book describes a period in Vancouver when police efforts were so effective that testing of street heroin found it contained no heroin at all. Yet users continued the same behaviors without withdrawal, suggesting that the psychological pattern persisted despite the chemical change. One of the best-known studies in this area is the "Rat Park" experiment conducted by the psychologist Bruce Alexander in the late 1970s. Earlier studies had placed rats alone in cages with access to drug-laced water and found heavy use. Alexander compared isolated rats with rats living in a spacious, enriched environment with other rats, both with free access to morphine. The rats in Rat Park consumed far less morphine than the isolated rats, in some measures about one-fifth as much. Rats moved from isolation into Rat Park also reduced their use. Alexander concluded that addiction is strongly shaped by environment, particularly by isolation, powerlessness, and a lack of purpose. Hari summarizes this view: "Addiction is a disease of loneliness." "Human beings only become addicted when they cannot find anything better to live for and when they desperately need to fill the emptiness that threatens to destroy them." Alexander's research lost its funding and was not continued. Hari also cites the neuroscientist Carl Hart: "Professor Carl Hart from Columbia University is one of the leading experts in the world on how drugs affect the brain. He tells me that when you explain these facts to the scientists who have built their careers on the simplistic old ideas about drugs, they effectively tell you... "leave me alone"... they just ignore you." Similarly, "Eric Sterling is the lawyer who wrote the drug laws for the United States between 1979 and 1989. ...He told [Hari] that if any government-funded scientist ever produced research suggesting anything beyond the conventional drugs-hijack-brains theory, [Sterling] knows exactly what would happen. The head of the NIDA would be called before a congressional committee and asked if she had gone mad. She might be fired. She would certainly be stopped." Tobacco offers a further illustration. Nicotine is among the most addictive substances, and many people in addiction treatment report that quitting smoking is harder than quitting the substance they sought treatment for. If addiction were purely chemical, nicotine replacement should be highly effective. Yet "The office of the Surgeon General has found that 17.7 percent of nicotine patch wearers were able to stop smoking." Most smokers did not quit despite receiving the chemical. Hari takes this as evidence that addiction cannot be explained by biology alone. Many researchers would describe addiction as the product of biological, psychological, and social factors together, but the book's emphasis is that the social and psychological dimensions have been badly neglected.

    Another misconception is that only humans seek out intoxicating substances. The book describes many animals that, given the opportunity, seek out intoxicants. Hari reports that water buffalo in Vietnam that normally avoided opium plants began eating them after being traumatized by the war. The parallel to human addiction is clear: trauma is widespread among people with severe addictions. On this basis, Hari argues that addiction is primarily psychological rather than primarily biological, and that people with addictions need treatment rather than punishment, community rather than isolation, and purpose rather than further trauma.

    The book then examines what happened in countries that changed their approach to drug use.

    In Liverpool, the psychiatrist John Marks ran a clinic that prescribed heroin to people with addictions during the 1980s, when the national government under Margaret Thatcher was taking a hard line on drugs. Marks observed that patients who received pharmaceutical heroin from the clinic generally lived stable, law-abiding lives, in contrast to people buying street heroin, which is frequently adulterated with unknown and harmful substances. He found that pure heroin at controlled doses caused far less physical damage than commonly believed. Many patients maintained jobs and families. When Marks extended prescribing to people who had been using street heroin, they too were able to stabilize. Hari reports that crime in the area fell by 93%.

    A related misconception is a slippery-slope assumption: that unchecked drug use inevitably continues for life. Marks found otherwise: "most addicts simply stopped of their own accord. They mature out of addiction... possibly because the stresses and strains of life are becoming stabilized for them and because the major challenges or adulthood have passed.'" "They usually do so after around ten years of use." The evidence suggests that most people do not use indefinitely and that many reduce or stop their use over time.

    A common concern is that people would use as much as possible if drugs were freely available. The evidence again points the other way. Patients often requested higher doses at first, but "within a few months, most addicts stop asking for more and choose, of their own free will, to stabilize their doses. After that, 'most of them want to go always down.'" A comparable program in Switzerland found that patients remained in the heroin-assisted treatment program for about three years on average, and that only around 15% were still using daily after that period. In Switzerland, the share of new HIV infections attributable to drug use fell from 68% to about 5%, and crime again declined substantially.

    A further concern is that wider access would create more addiction. In the Swiss case, the opposite occurred. The incidence of new heroin users fell from 207.54 per 100,000 people to 15.83. One explanation is that people with addictions often sell drugs to fund their own use, which recruits new users. When their supply is secured through treatment, that incentive disappears. Patients were "94.7 percent less likely to sell drugs than before their treatment." Public perceptions of addiction risk are also inflated. Carl Hart's research indicates that only about 20% of people who try crack cocaine go on to become addicted, despite its reputation, and most other drugs carry lower rates.

    A common objection is that taxpayers should not pay for people to use drugs. The Swiss data suggest that the alternative costs more: "The program costs thirty-five Swiss francs per patient per day, but it spares the taxpayer from having to spend forty-four francs a day arresting, trying, and convicting the drug user. So when people ask, 'Why should I pay for this?' the pragmatic Swiss answer is: This doesn't cost you money. It saves you money." In Hari's account, treatment is both less expensive and more effective than prohibition, while also reducing deaths and allowing more people to participate productively in society.

    The Liverpool program expanded because of its success, and two developments followed.

    First, crime declined further. Shoplifting dropped so significantly that retail chains publicly supported the program and sponsored an international conference on addiction treatment.

    Second, according to Hari, pressure from the United States contributed to the program being shut down.

    Portugal offers evidence about decriminalization. In 2001, Portugal decriminalized the personal possession of all drugs and redirected resources toward treatment and social reintegration. According to the figures Hari cites, drug use increased only slightly, from 3.4% to 3.7% of the population, while problematic drug use fell by roughly half, from about 100,000 people to about 50,000. The share of HIV infections linked to drug use fell from 52% to 20%. Countries that have continued prohibition have generally not seen comparable declines; in the United States, drug use has risen, as this article reports. Hari notes that Portugal's major parties across the political spectrum came to support the policy because of its results. In the Netherlands, where cannabis is tolerated, adult use is lower than in the United States, at 5% compared with 6.3%, and 21% of Dutch teenagers have tried marijuana compared with 45% of American teenagers. Hari argues that regulated access can make it harder for teenagers to obtain drugs than an unregulated illegal market does.

    The book also addresses the financial costs. According to the figures Hari cites, the United States spends about $41 billion per year on enforcement related to drug use. If currently illegal drugs were taxed at rates comparable to alcohol and tobacco, the estimated revenue would be about $46.7 billion per year. Together, this represents roughly $87.8 billion annually that could be redirected toward treatment and prevention, in addition to the reductions in crime, disease, and death described above.

    The author summarizes his arguments for legalization in his own words. Each argument is quoted below, followed by an explanation of the reasoning and evidence behind it:

    Arguments for Legalization

    1. "Across the world, armed criminal gangs selling drugs will be financially crippled, from the Crips to the Zetas. The survivors will be pushed into much less profitable markets, where they will be able to do much less harm. As a result, the culture of terror that currently dominates whole neighborhoods and countries - from Brownsville, Brooklyn, to Ciudad Juarez - will gradually abate (this happened after the end of alcohol prohibition)."Prohibition is what makes drugs so profitable for criminal organizations: because the product cannot be produced or sold legally, sellers can charge many times its cost and protect their market with force. Hari's argument is that removing this premium would remove the main source of funding for these groups. The historical parallel he draws is the repeal of alcohol prohibition in 1933, after which bootlegging organizations lost their most profitable trade and much of the associated street violence declined.
    2. "The murder rate will significantly fall (this also happened after the end of alcohol prohibition)."This follows from Miron's research cited earlier, which links the two largest spikes in the U.S. murder rate to periods of escalated prohibition. When disputes in a legal market are settled through contracts and courts, the need for violence to protect territory, enforce debts, and eliminate rivals largely disappears.
    3. "Enormous amounts of police time will be freed up to investigate other crimes."Drug enforcement absorbs a substantial share of police resources, from street arrests to surveillance and court time. Hari argues that redirecting this effort toward violent and property crimes would improve public safety more than the continued pursuit of drug users.
    4. "Trust in the police will begin to come back to poor communities (this happened in Portugal)."Aggressive drug enforcement tends to concentrate in poor neighborhoods, where it can make residents view police as adversaries rather than protectors. After Portugal decriminalized personal possession, police were no longer required to treat users as criminals, and Hari reports that relations between officers and the communities they served improved.
    5. "Teenagers will find it harder to get drugs (this happened in the Netherlands)."An illegal dealer has no reason to check a buyer's age, while a regulated, licensed seller risks losing that license by selling to minors. This helps explain the figures cited earlier, in which far fewer Dutch teenagers had tried marijuana than American teenagers despite cannabis being tolerated in the Netherlands.
    6. "Overdoses will significantly decline, and the rate of HIV transmission will fall dramatically (both happened in Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Vancouver)."Many overdoses happen because users cannot know the strength or contents of street drugs, and many HIV infections result from shared needles. Programs that supply drugs of known purity, provide clean equipment, and keep users in contact with medical staff address both causes directly. Hari points to the heroin-assisted treatment and harm-reduction programs in these places as evidence.
    7. "The drugs people use will, in the main, be milder than today (remember the iron law and the end of alcohol prohibition)."Hari refers to what is often called the "iron law of prohibition": when a substance is banned, the trade shifts toward its most concentrated forms, because smaller, stronger products are easier to smuggle and more profitable. During alcohol prohibition, spirits largely displaced beer, and after repeal, milder drinks returned. Hari argues that a legal market would similarly move away from the most potent forms of drugs.
    8. "There will be a lot more money to spend on treating addicts and dealing with the underlying causes of addiction. Many addicts who currently get worse behind bars will get better in hospitals and then new jobs. This means addiction will fall (this happened in Portugal)."Money currently spent on arrests, trials, and incarceration could instead fund treatment, housing, and employment support. Prison often deepens the isolation and trauma that Hari identifies as underlying causes of addiction, whereas treatment and reintegration address them. Portugal's decision to redirect resources in this way was followed by a roughly halved number of problematic drug users.
    9. "Millions of people who are currently imprisoned for nonviolent offenses, at great expense to the taxpayers and to their communities, will walk free."A large share of incarcerated people in the United States are held for drug-related, nonviolent offenses. Ending prohibition would remove the basis for many of these sentences, reducing public spending on incarceration and returning people to their families and communities.
    10. "Huge numbers of African American and Latino men who are currently locked out of the workforce, student loans, and public housing will be allowed back in."A drug conviction can bar people from employment, federal student aid, and public housing for years after their sentence ends. Because enforcement has fallen disproportionately on Black and Latino communities, these restrictions have compounded existing inequalities. Hari argues that legalization would remove one of the major barriers keeping these men from rebuilding their lives.
    11. "Shaming addicts will be replaced by caring for addicts."This final point reflects the book's central theme. If addiction arises largely from pain, isolation, and a lack of connection, then punishment and stigma deepen the very conditions that sustain it. Hari concludes that a compassionate response, one that reconnects people to community and purpose, is both more humane and more effective.

    A final point concerns the substances that are already legal. Alcohol and tobacco are among the most harmful drugs in widespread use. A study published in The Lancet, led by David Nutt, rated drugs according to their combined harm to users and to others. Alcohol ranked highest, with a score of 72 out of 100, followed by heroin at 55, crack cocaine at 54, and methamphetamine at 33. By this measure, alcohol was rated roughly twice as harmful as methamphetamine. Hari argues that these findings expose an inconsistency in current policy: substances with lower measured harm, such as cannabis, remain illegal while some of the most harmful substances are legal and widely accepted.

    Was This Book Summary Helpful?

    Someone else is about to decide whether this book summary is worth their time. Your rating is what helps them choose.

    5.0

    4 ratings

    Rate This Book Summary

    All ratings are anonymous

    Anonymous Comments

    (0)

    What clicked for you in this book summary could be what makes it click for the next reader.

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

    Link blocked? Copy it and paste in a new browser tab.