Black Sun

    A History of Indian Philosophy

    by Surendranath Dasgupta

    A History of Indian Philosophy

    by Surendranath Dasgupta

    A History of Indian Philosophy is Surendranath Dasgupta's comprehensive survey of the major schools of thought that arose in ancient India. Dasgupta, a Bengali philosopher and scholar of Sanskrit, traces how these traditions grew out of a shared body of sacred literature, debated one another over many centuries and arrived at strikingly different answers to the same fundamental questions: What is the self? What is ultimately real? Why do people suffer, and how can they become free?

    The survey covers Buddhism and Jainism, which broke away from the older religious establishment, alongside the six orthodox schools of Hindu thought: Samkhya, Yoga, Nyaya, Vaisesika, Mimamsa and Vedanta. Each school is introduced below in turn. Their texts and doctrines took shape gradually, across many centuries, rather than within a single era.

    Nearly all of these traditions begin, whether in agreement or reaction, with the Vedas, the oldest collections of sacred literature in Sanskrit, the classical language of ancient India. The Vedas were composed and passed down orally over many generations and contain hymns, ritual instructions and, in their later portions, philosophical reflection.

    The Vedas

    • Many Hindu traditions regard the Vedas as revelation that was heard by ancient sages rather than composed by human authors.
    • Accepting the authority of the Vedas is what defines a school as orthodox, although the schools interpret them in very different ways.
    • Vedic literature is divided into four kinds of text, each building on the one before:
      • Samhita - The core collections of hymns, chants and ritual formulas, which make up the four Vedas:
        • Rigveda - The oldest Veda, consisting of hymns of praise addressed to the gods.
        • Sama-Veda - Liturgical chants, largely adapted from Rigvedic verses.
        • Yajur-Veda - Formulas recited by priests while performing sacrificial rituals.
        • Atharva-Veda - Hymns, healing charms and protective rites concerned with everyday life.
      • Brahmanas - Prose commentaries explaining how rituals should be performed and what they mean.
      • Aranyakas - "Forest texts," studied by those who withdrew from society, which treat the rituals as symbols to be contemplated rather than acts to be performed.
      • Upanisads (Upanishads) - The final and most philosophical portion, which turns from ritual toward questions about the nature of the self, ultimate reality and liberation from suffering.

    Dasgupta shows how the understanding of the divine changed over the course of the Vedas. The earliest hymns praise many gods, but they practice what scholars call henotheism, which Dasgupta defines as "a belief in single gods, each in turn standing out as the highest." Whichever god a hymn addresses is praised as supreme in that moment. Over time, the hymns begin to search for a single source behind all the gods, given names such as Prajapati, "lord of creatures," Visvakarma, "maker of all," and eventually Brahman, the ultimate reality underlying everything.

    In the same period, sacrifice came to be seen as the force that sustains the order of the cosmos, so powerful that even the gods depended on it. The ideas of karma, the principle that every action produces consequences, and rebirth, the cycle of being born again into new lives, gradually emerge in the later Vedic texts and become central in the Upanishads. One Vedic creation image describes the universe emerging from a golden embryo, or cosmic egg. A declassified military report on altered states of consciousness also describes the universe in egg-shaped terms; the report is available in the Linked Document.

    The Upanishads turn the focus inward. Rather than relying on outward ritual, they teach that true understanding comes through knowledge and contemplation. Their central concern is the atman, the innermost self, and its relationship to Brahman. The Taittiriya Upanishad, for example, describes the self as wrapped in five layers, from the most physical to the most subtle: the body nourished by food, the vital breath, the mind, the understanding and, innermost, bliss. These ideas became the starting point for the philosophical schools that followed.

    Eight Systems of Philosophy

    1) Early Indian Philosophy

    Indian philosophy divides its schools into two groups. The astika, or orthodox, schools accept the authority of the Vedas; the nastika, or heterodox, schools reject it. The distinction concerns the Vedas, not belief in God: some orthodox schools have no creator God at all. Buddhism, Jainism and the materialist Carvaka school are heterodox. The six orthodox schools, each examined in more detail below, are:

    • Yoga teaches a practical discipline of meditation for freeing consciousness. It recognizes Isvara, a supreme self that serves as a model for practitioners rather than a creator of the world.
    • Samkhya divides reality into two principles: pure consciousness and material nature. In its classical form, it explains the world without a creator God.
    • Vedanta means "the end of the Vedas" and builds its philosophy on the Upanishads, asking how the individual self relates to Brahman.
    • Mimamsa focuses on correctly interpreting the Vedas and performing the duties and rituals they command.
    • Nyaya is the school of logic. It studies how people can know things reliably and how to reason and debate correctly, seeing clear thinking as a path to liberation.
    • Vaisesika sorts everything that exists into basic categories, such as substances, qualities and motion, and teaches that physical things are built from indivisible atoms.

    Most of these schools share a common framework. They hold that actions produce karma, that karma binds beings to a cycle of rebirth and suffering, and that the highest goal is moksa, or liberation from that cycle. They differ sharply, however, on what the self is, how karma operates and what liberation consists of. The orthodox schools generally hold that each person has an enduring self, while Buddhism denies that any permanent self exists.

    2) Early Buddhist Philosophy

    Buddhism began with the teachings of Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, and developed through centuries of debate with the other Indian schools. Its central teachings are that life involves suffering, that everything is impermanent, that all things arise in dependence on other things rather than existing on their own, a principle called dependent origination, and that there is no permanent, unchanging self. Early Buddhist thought describes the physical world in terms of four elements, earth, water, fire and air, understood as qualities such as solidity, cohesion, heat and motion.

    As Buddhism spread, it divided into schools that disagreed about how the mind relates to the world it perceives. Dasgupta describes the following major approaches.

    Major Buddhist Approaches:

    1. Mahayana
      • Mahayana, "the great vehicle," holds up the ideal of the bodhisattva, a being who seeks enlightenment not only for themselves but in order to free all living beings from suffering.
      • Its key teaching is emptiness: nothing exists independently or by its own nature, because everything depends on causes and conditions.
    2. Tathata
      • Tathata means "suchness": reality exactly as it is, before the mind divides it into labels and categories.
      • On this view, suchness is always present, but ignorance and ingrained habits of thought hide it.
      • Awakening is therefore not the creation of something new but the recognition of what was there all along.
      • Ignorance keeps a person unenlightened in three connected ways:
        • It sets the mind in restless motion, which produces suffering.
        • It divides experience into a perceiver and things perceived, creating the sense of a separate self.
        • It makes objects seem to exist independently, so that the self becomes attached to them.
      • A Buddha is one who has fully awakened to suchness.
        • Awakening joins wisdom with compassion for all living beings.
    3. Madhyamika/Sunyavada
      • Madhyamika, "the middle way," founded by the philosopher Nagarjuna, argues that because everything arises in dependence on something else, nothing, including the self, has any independent existence. This is what it means by sunya, or "empty."
      • Emptiness does not mean that nothing matters: things still function in everyday life, and actions still carry moral consequences.
    4. Vijnanavada
      • Vijnanavada, "the doctrine of consciousness," also known as Yogacara, teaches that the objects people experience are shaped by consciousness itself rather than existing independently outside it. Liberation comes from transforming consciousness so that the split between the perceiver and the perceived falls away.

    3) Early Jaina Philosophy

    Jainism arose in the same era as Buddhism and, like it, rejected the authority of the Vedas. Jains revere a line of twenty-four tirthankaras, "ford-makers" who crossed the river of rebirth and showed others the way. The twenty-fourth and most recent, Mahavira, was a contemporary of the Buddha. Jainism later divided into two communities, the Svetambaras, or "white-clad," whose monks wear white robes, and the Digambaras, or "sky-clad," whose monks renounce all clothing. They also differ on which scriptures survive: the Svetambaras preserve eleven texts called the Angas, while the Digambaras hold that the original scriptures were lost. Both agree that the oldest texts, the Purvas, have been lost.

    The core teachings of Jainism concern nonviolence, the many-sided nature of truth and the soul's bondage to karma.

    Core Teachings of Jainism:

    • Ahimsa, or nonviolence, is the central Jain value and extends to every living thing, including insects and microscopic beings.
    • Everything has an enduring substance and changing forms. Gold can become a ring and then a necklace while remaining gold, so permanence and change exist together.
    • Anekantavada, "many-sidedness," teaches that reality has many aspects and that any single viewpoint captures only part of the truth. Only a fully liberated, all-knowing soul sees the whole.
    • Knowledge comes in several forms: through the senses, through reasoning, through scripture and through extraordinary spiritual perception.
    • The soul is naturally capable of perfect knowledge and perception, but karma clouds these abilities.
    • Jainism sees life far more widely than most traditions: souls inhabit not only humans and animals but also plants and tiny beings living in earth, water, fire and air.
    • The universe is made of six substances: souls, matter, space, time, and two media that make motion and rest possible.
    • Matter is made of atoms, each possessing qualities of color, taste, smell and touch.
    • Unlike other schools, Jainism treats karma as a fine physical substance that sticks to the soul. Passions such as anger and greed act like glue, binding more karma to it.

    Five Causes of Karmic Bondage:

    1. Delusions - Holding false beliefs that prevent a person from seeing reality clearly.
    2. Lack of Restraint - Failing to refrain from violence, lying, stealing, sexual misconduct and possessiveness.
    3. Inadvertence - Carelessness and inattention, which lead to harm done without thought.
    4. Activities of the Body, Mind, and Speech - Every action, word and thought draws karma toward the soul.
    5. Passions - Anger, pride, deceit and greed, which bind karma most tightly of all.

    Practices for Restraining Karmic Influx:

    1. One must take "vows of non-injury, truthfulness, abstinence from stealing, sex control, and non-acceptance of objects of desire."
    2. Moving and speaking carefully so as not to harm any living being.
    3. Restraining the body, speech and mind.
    4. Instilling "habits of forgiveness, humility, straightforwardness, truth, cleanliness, restraint, penance, abandonment, indifference to any kind of gain or loss, and supreme sex-control."
    5. Meditating on purity, personal responsibility and the nature of truth.
    6. Enduring hardships such as heat, cold and physical discomfort with calm.
    7. Living by right conduct in every part of life.

    When the passions are overcome, new karma stops binding to the soul, and the karma already accumulated gradually falls away. The person then meditates on universal friendliness and compassion toward all beings, including calm forbearance toward those who do wrong. The final goal is moksa, the state in which the soul, free of all karma, enjoys infinite knowledge and happiness. Because the soul achieves this through its own effort, Jainism has no need for a creator God, as the following argument expresses:

    "

    If god is guided by man's moral order then he is not independent.

    4) Early Yoga Philosophy

    Yoga, systematized in the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, is the practical companion to Samkhya philosophy. It distinguishes purusa, pure consciousness, the silent witness at the core of every person, from prakrti, material nature, which includes not only the body but also the mind and its thoughts. Suffering arises because consciousness mistakes itself for the restless activity of the mind. Yoga aims to end this confusion through what Dasgupta calls the "perfected discipline of the will and psychological control of the mental states."

    According to Samkhya, material nature is made up of three gunas, or qualities, present in different proportions in everything: sattva, the quality of clarity and balance; rajas, the quality of activity and desire; and tamas, the quality of heaviness and inertia. The first thing to emerge from nature is buddhi, the intellect. Liberation comes when a person clearly recognizes that consciousness is separate from all of nature, including the intellect itself.

    Yoga teaches that every experience leaves an impression in the mind, and that these impressions, accumulated over this and previous lives, shape a person's habits and tendencies. For this reason, understanding the philosophy is not enough; it must be supported by long and steady practice that gradually loosens these patterns. Yoga names five afflictions that keep consciousness bound.

    Five Afflictions That Obstruct Liberation:

    1. Ignorance (Avidya) - Mistaking what is temporary, impure, painful and not the self for what is permanent, pure, pleasant and the self. The other four afflictions grow from this one.
    2. Asmita - Egoism: confusing the witnessing consciousness with the mind and senses it uses.
    3. Raga - Attachment: clinging to whatever has brought pleasure.
    4. Dvesa - Aversion: pushing away whatever has brought pain.
    5. Abhinivesa - The instinctive clinging to life and fear of death, present even in the wise.

    Yoga calls the mind citta and identifies five kinds of mental activity: correct knowledge, error, imagination, sleep and memory. Patanjali defines yoga itself as the stilling of these activities. When the mind becomes still, consciousness is no longer confused with the thoughts passing through it, and it rests in its own nature.

    Meditation alone is not enough. Yoga begins with ethical discipline, including nonviolence, truthfulness, not stealing, sexual restraint and freedom from greed, because a mind disturbed by harmful conduct cannot become still.

    5&6) Nyaya/Vaisesika Philosophies

    Nyaya and Vaisesika began as separate schools but became so closely connected that they are often studied together. Vaisesika takes its name from visesa, "particularity," the quality that makes each thing distinct. It sorts everything that exists into categories, such as substances, qualities and motion, and teaches that physical objects are made of eternal, indivisible atoms that combine to form the world.

    Nyaya is above all a school of logic. It holds that suffering stems from false knowledge, so learning to reason correctly and to test claims through careful debate is itself a path to freedom. Vaisesika adds that understanding the true nature of reality, together with right action, leads to liberation.

    In Vaisesika, the word karma has a technical meaning, physical motion, in addition to its moral sense. Nyaya identifies four reliable sources of knowledge: perception, inference, comparison and the testimony of trustworthy people. Later thinkers in these schools developed arguments for Isvara, God, as the intelligence who arranges the atoms into an ordered world. Liberation, for both schools, is the soul's final release from all suffering.

    7) Mimamsa Philosophy

    Mimamsa, meaning "investigation," is devoted to interpreting the Vedas and especially the duties and rituals they command. To defend the Vedas as a source of truth, it developed a detailed theory of knowledge. Many Mimamsa thinkers held that knowledge is self-validating: a belief should be accepted as true unless something shows it to be mistaken. They excluded memory as a source of new knowledge, since it only repeats what was already known, and carefully distinguished perception from other ways of knowing.

    8) Sankara School of Vedanta

    Vedanta reaches its most influential form in Advaita, "non-dual," Vedanta, taught by the eighth-century philosopher Sankara. Sankara taught that the atman, the individual self, and Brahman, ultimate reality, are not two separate things but one and the same. People suffer because ignorance makes them believe they are separate, limited selves. Liberation comes through knowledge that dispels this ignorance, and the mind must be prepared for that knowledge through ethical and spiritual discipline.

    Preparation for Vedanta Requires Four Disciplines:

    1. Discrimination between what is eternal and what is temporary.
    2. Detachment from the rewards of action, whether in this life or the next.
    3. "Attainment of peace, self-restraint, renunciation, patience, deep concentration, and faith."
    4. An intense desire for liberation.

    For Sankara, Brahman alone is ultimately real. The everyday world of separate people and objects is not simply nonexistent, but its apparent independence is an illusion produced by ignorance, much as a rope seen in dim light can be mistaken for a snake. When true knowledge arises, the person realizes that their own self has always been Brahman, and they are freed from the cycle of rebirth.

    Conclusion

    A History of Indian Philosophy shows that Indian thought is not a single worldview but a long and rigorous conversation carried on across many centuries. Beginning with the hymns and rituals of the Vedas and turning inward with the Upanishads, Indian philosophers came to ask the same fundamental questions: What is the self? What is ultimately real? Why do beings suffer, and how can they be freed?

    The schools Dasgupta examines answer these questions in strikingly different ways. Buddhism denies that any permanent self exists and seeks freedom through insight into impermanence and emptiness. Jainism treats karma as a physical substance that clings to the soul and seeks freedom through nonviolence and strict self-discipline. Samkhya and Yoga separate pure consciousness from material nature and teach that liberation comes when consciousness stops mistaking itself for the mind. Nyaya and Vaisesika seek freedom through correct reasoning and a clear understanding of the categories of reality, while Mimamsa defends the authority of the Vedas and the duties they prescribe. Sankara's Vedanta concludes that the individual self and ultimate reality were never separate at all.

    Despite these differences, nearly all of the schools share a common conviction: that suffering is rooted in ignorance about the true nature of the self and the world, and that the highest purpose of philosophy is not merely to understand reality but to become free. Dasgupta's achievement is to present each tradition as a serious system of thought in its own right, revealing Indian philosophy as one of humanity's richest and most sustained inquiries into consciousness, reality and liberation.

    Was This Book Summary Helpful?

    Someone else is about to decide whether this book summary is worth their time. Your rating is what helps them choose.

    5.0

    3 ratings

    Rate This Book Summary

    All ratings are anonymous

    Anonymous Comments

    (0)

    What clicked for you in this book summary could be what makes it click for the next reader.

    No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

    Link blocked? Copy it and paste in a new browser tab.